Thinking of Dying my Hair RED!!

I have been a red head before. I was a red head through most of high school but that was 10 years ago and I have not been a red head since. It is funny because when I first met John's family - when we first started dating they just assumed that I was a natural red head - and obviously John is a red head. So when I dyed it a different color both is mother and one of his cousins said to me - oh you should go back to your natural red color - I had to tell them that my natural color is brown.

I dyed my hair back to my natural color in December - because we are trying to save for IVF and that is one of the first expenses to go - hair highlighting - it is just too expensive - but I am already just so sick of my mousy brown hair - I need a change. Dye is cheaper than highlights.

Here is a pictures of John and I back in the day - it is not a very good picture - but I have red hair. I do not know - what do you think?? Should I dye it red?? Can you tell I have a hard time making a decision myself. I am a very indecisive.